Heroism and Saxon Achievement: The Old English poetic kian pishkar In 797, the Northumbrian scholar Alcuin, resident in the Frankish slant of Charlemagne, inquired of Higbald, bishop of Lindisfarne, Quid Hinieldus cum Christo (DÃ¼mmler 183) (What has Ingeld to do with Christ?), raising issues butt the relationship between Christianity and Germanic society and culture explored by numerous modern commentators, from J. R. R. Tolkien to Michael D. Cherniss and others. By his question, Alcuin declared succinctly his differ disapproval of the fondness displayed by the monks of Lindisfarne (and doubtless elsewhere) for listening to stomach song and poetry rather than to sacred wisdom. Ingeld was a imperious figure from Germanic tradition whose renown is attested by the bareness of the allusion to his story in the Beowulf poem (lines 2020 ff.) and the weight of high-minded legend with which Alcuin burdened him (Tolkien, Beowulf 22).1 Christ was of course the proper idealist ic for Christian monks. Alcuins rhetorical query stands in a long tradition initiated by St. Paul in his hatful Epistle to the Corinthians: [W]hat concord hath Christ with Belial? (6:15). The paradox was perhaps expressed skilful clearly by the early perform Father Tertullians What has Athens to do with Jerusalem?
What has the Academy to do with the perform? or St. Jeromes three-fold query What does Horace have to do with the Psalter? Maro with the church building doctrine? Cicero with the Apostles? (Brown 482). As Maro was Virgil, the pagan poet of the heroic epic on the initiation of Rome, Jeromes question most closely parallels that of Alcuin in the! face-off of pre-Christian heroism to Christian teachings. It is obvious from the literary and diachronic stage setting that for Alcuin the pagan and adult malely nature of the songs socialize the Lindisfarne community do them utterly unsuited for recitation in the monastic refectory where attendance should be given not to the concerns of this world but to the next. In the...If you want to get a proficient essay, order it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com
If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper